Tales From the Mutiny Kitchen: Sourdough Bread Success

If you follow us on Instagram you’ve probably had your fill of sourdough bread photos. I’m starting to fear that our gluten-free friends may be experiencing symptoms simply from the amount of carb-laden images flooding their feed. Sorry about that! I have attempted a gf sourdough but it was not tasty (and required expensive ingredients as well as a lot of babying). Anyway, I thought maybe it was time to do a little write up on the baking going on in the Mutiny Kitchen.

I started baking sourdough back when we were still RVing. That presented plenty of challenges, from unstable temperatures for fermenting to baking in a small convection oven. Most of those loaves ended up more like door stops. I don’t enjoy failure…so I bought a bread machine and decided commercial yeast was just fine.

This loaf was made (partially) with locally grown wheat berries I ground in my Vitamix. Our goat, Ewan, approved!

Now that we’re trying our hand at farm life, and eating more local foods, I thought I’d give sourdough another shot. Our town is home to a local mill so I knew if I could actually capture the wild yeast and create a starter, my bread would be almost 100% local (aside from the salt) and I wouldn’t have to buy commercial yeasts. Unfortunately, my initial attempts at making a starter failed, over and over again. I even tried using homemade kombucha in place of the water but the bread ended up too sour for our tastes.

My first loaves leavened with fruit fermented water.

I persevered. And now my loaves are much, much better. As a matter of fact, people are even buying them at the Farmer’s Market. So, how did I go from making door stops to sellable loaves? Practice. And a lot of copying. After all, lots of people are successfully baking sourdough breads and, with a history dating back to at least 3700 B.C.E. (the naturally leavened loaf was discovered in Switzerland) and commercial yeasts being relatively young (about 150 years old) there are only so many original recipes for a simple loaf. A simple loaf is, after all, simply flour, water and salt. There are blog post, Facebook groups, cook books, in-person and online classes available galore. Even so, sourdough baking presents some challenges so I thought I’d compile a list of things that helped in my bread making journey.

The List:

1- Use a scale. My breads improved immediately by simply measuring my ingredients by weight instead of relying on measuring cups. You’ll read ‘recipes’ that say using equal amounts of water and flour will create a great starter. If you think a half cup of water and a half cup of flour are equal measures you’d be wrong. Seriously, get a scale. Measure by grams. Pretty soon you’ll wish every recipe you follow would use weight measurements. Don’t be intimidated! {The first Amazon pic is my “dream” scale, mainly because it has an available ac adapter and doesn’t need batteries. The second is the scale I currently own. It works great for everything I need to do and is currently less than $10.}. This is seriously the NUMBER ONE TIP that changed my level of success with baking sourdough.

2- Try fermented water. I was able to get a much more stable starter by fermenting fruit first. Confused? Well, let me explain. Although flour has natural yeast in it (most organic foods do) it can be a slow process to ferment (like weeks). A lot of people get frustrated and it’s a pain to feed your starter all the time without being able to see any results. I learned (through a Facebook group) about fermented water and absolutely love the results. Here’s the basic recipe:

2 apples (chopped into chunks with peels, seeds, core and all)
600 grams of water
2 TBS dried fruit (raisins, cherries, cranberries, etc)

Place all ingredients into a large mason jar and seal with 2 piece lid. Every day you’ll want to shake the jar and off-gas it (meaning unscrew the lid to let any built up gases and then secure it again).
After a few days (depending on your home’s temperatures) your fruit should ferment and you’ll get a nice fizz when you open the jar. Once it’s fizzy, like a can of soda, it’s ready to use. Strain off the fruit and save the liquid.
To make your starter mix 50g of whole wheat flour with 50g of ferment water. Eight hours (or so) later, add another 50g whole wheat flour and 50g ferment water. After another 8 hours add 150g whole wheat flour and 150g ferment water. Your starter should be pretty active in just a few hours. Look for lots of bubbles in the flour.
A few hours after the last feeding your starter is ready to use. Use it in any recipe/formula that calls for 100% hydration starter. If you aren’t using it that day you’ll need to continue to feed it (and also discard some of it or it will get very sour) or put it in the fridge. There is a lot of information out there on how to maintain a starter. Google is your friend.

Note: I use apples and dried cherries since I have these growing on my property. I’ve also used banana peels (instead of apples) and store bought raisins but apples work best for me. In the past I’ve used all of my starter to bake my loaves and simply created a new starter each week. Now I keep my starter going by saving a bit when I bake and simply feeding it whole wheat flour and plain water once I run out of ferment water.

3- Use a Dutch Oven. Okay, it doesn’t have to be a dutch over per se, but baking your bread at higher temperatures and with a cover will help capture the steam and lead to better oven spring and that lovely crust everyone seems to love. I scored a Lodge enamel dutch oven for $15 at a yard sale last year and also bought a new Lodge cast iron dutch oven (non-enameled) so I could bake two loaves at a time. Later, I found an apple baker, which is a clay baker, at the thrift store…and I love it. Alternatives include a baking stone with a roasting pan lid, a Granite Wear roasting pan or even a cast iron frying pan with one of those disposable aluminum foil trays as a lid. I generally bake my loaves at around 480 F (covered) for the first 25 minutes and then at 450 F (uncovered) for 12-15 additional minutes which allows the bread to brown nicely. Oh, and I allow my dutch oven to preheat in the oven for 1 hour before adding the bread dough. I also douse my dough generously with water (I use an inexpensive spray bottle)…directly on the loaf…before placing it in the oven. The lid helps retain the steam and allows for that beautiful oven-spring (rise) and the blisters on the crust so many people desire.

4- No Need to Knead. Learn the Stretch and Fold instead. Once you learn just a tiny bit about the science behind gluten you’ll find that kneading sourdough isn’t necessary. The Stretch and Fold will help your dough ferment and breakdown the gluten so your bread is light and fluffy.

5- Don’t cut it too soon! I know…it’s pure torture waiting for a fresh new loaf to cool completely before slicing. When I was a kid one of the best things on earth was getting the first piece of bread, fresh from the oven, whenever my mom baked. Those were yeast loaves…not sourdough. Sourdough continues to cook and the flavors keep developing even after you take it out of the oven. Place your ear near your hot loaf (carefully!!)…hear that popping and cracking?? The magic is still happening. Wait until your loaf is completely cool (or at least and hour) to cut into it.

6- Join a Sourdough Group and/or Take a Course. I actually did both. I’m in a Facebook group called Perfect Sourdough which led me to the Udemy Course called Sourdough 101 (this affiliate link costs you nothing extra but helps pay for our web hosting, thanks!). Not only will you gain access to some fabulous recipes but you can get some quick feedback (or troubleshooting help) in the FB group. I recently completed the Sourdough 101 course and have gained a better understanding of the steps involved to make a consistently great loaf of bread.

7- Watch some YouTube videos. Love it or hate it YouTube has it’s value. It has saved us a crap ton of money in repairs of various items on the RV and on the farm. It’s also helped me with everything from gardening and composting to canning and baking bread. Yes, our internet is still crappy, and expensive, and NOT unlimited…so I often get up early so I can utilize our extra gigabytes just so I can watch tutorials. I highly recommend anything by Theresa Greenway and/or NorthWest Sourdough. I also recommend this new video by my friend Amy Hager, of Colorado Mountain Living. She created this video based on the recipe I shared with her. Many of us at higher elevations struggle with baking. I’m at about 5500′ and Amy is above 9000′ and this method has been a proven winner for both of us. But it’s also an excellent method for those at sea level and beginners.

Here’s the recipe I started with which is explained in the above video (this recipe was shared in a FB group by baker Piotr Lesnianski). Note that Amy does hers just slightly different than mine…mostly in the dough mixing sequence.

Basic Sourdough with Fruit Yeast Starter

* Place 500 grams of the starter listed above (which should be all of it) in a large bowl
* Add any remaining fermented water to the starter so it all weighs 1500 grams TOTAL (use regular tap water to make up any difference). To be clear, the starter PLUS the water should be 1500 grams TOTAL.
* Add 1500 grams of flour (I use local white)
* Mix well so there are not longer any dry spots
* Let this autolyze…which simply means place the bowl in a warmish spot, covered for 2 hours to allow the flour to absorb the moisture and the gluten to start to develop

* After 2 hours add 34 grams (about 2 TBS) salt
* Perform your first stretch and fold to incorporate the salt…you will actually stretch and fold with dough 4 times (north to south, south to north, east to west and west to east) for each S&F session. Pro tip: Use wet hands and wet them often. This is not the time for dusting with flour as this will change the consistency of your dough.
* Let the dough rest in a warmish spot again for 45 minutes.
* Perform 3 more S&F series every 45 minutes.
* After the last 45 min rest divide your dough into 3 equal sections (I use a scale) and shape into round loaves (look at YouTube for shaping tutorials). Be sure to dust your shaped loaves with rice flour so they don’t stick to the proofing bowls!
* Place in bannetons or bowls that have been dusted with additional rice flour (top of loaf goes down, seam side is up)
* Cover with a wet linen clothe, wet flour sack or plastic wrap and place in the fridge overnight
* In the morning, heat your oven to 480 degrees F being sure to place your dutch oven, clay baker, pizza stone and roasting lid or other baking dish in the oven to preheat as well.
* After an hour carefully remove the baker and gently place your dough inside. I like to use high temperature parchment paper to make a “sling” for my dough. So, carefully invert your cold (straight from the fridge) loaf into your hand and place it on your parchment paper. You can score your loaf now.
* Lower your loaf gently into the baker, spray generously with water and place the lid on top.
* Bake for 25 minutes at 480 degrees F. Then remove lid (hopefully you’ll see a beautiful oven spring and gorgeous loaf developing). Place back in the oven without the lid. Lower the temperature to 425-450 degrees F and bake for an additional 12-15 minutes.
* Once the time is up be sure to remove your loaf from the baker and place on a cooling rack for at least an hour before slicing. The loaf should be completely cool before slicing for best flavor development and for ease of cutting.

I encourage you to start with this basic recipe and follow it as closely as possible. Once you get a nice loaf and see how things work you can then experiment with other flours like whole wheat or rye. You can also add things like walnuts, dates, spices, seeds, cheese, etc to the stretch and folds…but again, I recommend getting a basic loaf down first so you can learn how the dough should feel before changing things too much.

Other helpful tool I use: Note that I always try to find these types of items at the thrift stores first but, when all else fails, Amazon comes through. They aren’t necessary to making a nice loaf but, if you bake often you may find them handy:

These are nice for turning the dough and for scrapping the counter after dusting or shaping. Makes for a quick cleanup.

Obviously any bowls will do but I got this set for Christmas and love them for several reasons. One, they are glass and therefore non-reactive to the many things I ferment (including sourdough). Two, they have lids, perfect for keeping dough moist and protected. Three, the big one is big so when I am mixing a large amount of dough (enough for 3 loaves) it can hold it all.

Okay, so Danish Dough Whisks are a luxury…but I found one at a yard sale for like $2 and I love it so much. Even new they aren’t too expensive. Granted, you can use your hands to mix your dough…and many people love that connection with their bread, but I sometimes make so much that I find my hands dry out…so I use this whisk.

Bannetons are just nice bowls for resting and proofing your dough before baking. You can use any bowl really but these give that nice ribbed texture (if you don’t use the linen liner) that you see at a lot of bakeries. I like using mine simply for the aesthetics.

While you don’t have to score your dough most people do so they can control where it splits when it rises in the oven. These razors are my favorite. You can make a lame by threading a blade (carefully) through a chopstick or wooden kebob or, if you’re comfortable, just hold the blade carefully while you score. Scoring is an art and can be used to make decorative and elaborate designs on your loaves. There are loads of YouTube videos and Instagram posts showing examples of scoring. It takes patience and practice…like all things baking.

Disclosure: Tales From the Mutiny (aka Clark and Lynn Bonelli) is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com. Our aim is to link to products we actually use and recommend.

Disclosure: We write about stuff we think you’ll like. We aim to highlight products and services you might find interesting, and if you buy them, we may get a small share of the revenue from the sale from our partner, Udemy.